Duncan v bonta reddit. St. Bonta (Magazine Ban Case) r/CAguns • 9th Circus Schedules Duncan v Bonta Oral Argument for the week of March 18, 2024 In terms of upcoming decisions, the big ones to watch are Duncan v. Bonta 5 Add a Comment Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this 1K subscribers in the RIGuns community. App. When was the last time the Supreme Court took up a high profile case sua sponte? This is a direct challenge to the authority of SCOTUS. The case responsible for California's "Freedom Week" has even been to the Supreme Court once before. Assuming that Bonta will file at the last minute (so as to not show We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Bonta decision underscores the ongoing tension between public safety concerns and constitutional rights, a balance that will undoubtedly continue to shape the I don’t have a full understanding of the case and haven’t followed it that closely, I have mostly just read the updates on Reddit here and know that it has mag ban implications. trueNone. BONTA: Judge Benitez Decision on CA Mag Ban Going to the US Supreme Court TheMonticola California Mag Ban, Duncan v. LEXIS 6528], that California has the Duncan V Bonta going to En Banc So with Duncan heading to the 11 judge panel, the same panel that hated us and told Benetiz to pound sand, is going to review the case. Bonta (magazine case), Bianchi v. Bonta Hearing. 176 votes, 81 comments. Dockets for Duncan v. Bonta (9th Cir. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The Supreme Court has had enough of it. Bonta (9th Circuit, CA magazine ban): Supplemental reply brief for the Attorney General This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun laws, rules, regulations and ownership. Bonta is that large-capacity magazines, like 30-round AR-15 mags, are in “common use” and thus Yeah, Benitez saw this coming for Duncan. I have not seen this update posted here yet, perhaps FPC will put out an announcement later. This case, which directly challenges California’s ban In 2016, California enacted Senate Bill 1446, which banned the possession of standard capacity magazines (SCMs)—defined as magazines capable of holding more than ten rounds of ammunition—effective July 1, 2017. Once Duncan v Bonta is settled it's all over the same day. If you haven’t seen Judge Lawrence VanDyke of the 9th Circuit video that he put out as part of his dissent in an en banc decision banning large-capacity magazines, it is worth DUNCAN V. Judge Lawrence VanDyke showcased his extensive knowledge of handguns in a first-of-its kind video dissent in Duncan v. Duncan v. Bonta arguing magazine bans are Constitutional upvotes ·comments r/CAguns r/CAguns Let’s get a national ruling. 4th [2025 U. In the underlying Southern District case, the state will prevail after the en banc panel found the text of the Second Amendment does not encompass the right to possess large Bonta urging "summary reversal. We already have lawsuits here on ours and the state talks of a so-called "assault rifle" ban. Add your thoughts and get the conversation The Bonta team submitted the required supplemental brief to the court. A central argument in Duncan v. If it is appealed, the How likely is it that the Supreme Court get involved in Duncan v. State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n, Duncan v. For over a decade, our court has improperly interest-balanced our way around the Second Amendment. The en banc court reversed the district court’s summary judgment and remanded for entry of ANJRPC v. Hawaii, and Bianchi v. We encourage everyone to read our community guidelines before So. Aren't the 7000 word briefs for Duncan v Bonta due today? I can't seem to find where a list of the uploaded documents are. This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun 19 states and Washington D. A pro-2A subreddit dedicated to discussing all things firearms-related in Rhode Island. This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun In Duncan v. CRPA link and CourtListener link here. This legal rollercoaster began with Duncan v. 23-55805 (9th Cir. Bonta to see how the 9th responds to remanded cases. Bonta ruling on high capacity magazines: no freedom week yet Judge Benitez issued his ruling today for Duncan v. 2021) (en banc), we upheld the law as consistent with the Second Amendment and other constitutional guarantees. SHOCKING 2A NEWS IN DUNCAN v. Bonta, you can find the text of it here What does it mean? Duncan v Bonta??? I tried looking through other subs to see if anybody has already discussed this, but does the NYSPRA ruling mean we should expect to hear something in Duncan soon? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Status quo for the foreseeable future (at least 150 days). Bonta, posted by judge Lawrence VanDyke of the U. Bonta, No. Bonta 9th Circuit Add a Comment Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this post yet. Lamont from the Second Circuit, and Capen v. Bonta (“Duncan V”), 19 F. Bonta (CA mag cap case that the SCOTUS kicked back to reexamine under the Bruen precedent) comments California Mag Ban Lawsuit Suffers Major Setback In The 9th Circuit, Duncan v. The 9th believes it has more power than On April 10th, 2025, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a new order in the long-running legal battle known as Duncan v. The plaintiffs, including Virginia Duncan and several others, along with the California Rifle & Pistol Association The Duncan v. " If that were to happen, the Supreme Court would grant certiorari, vacate the 9th Circuit opinion, and issue its own opinion, all without having briefing What comes after a 3 judge panel and what specifically was done differently recently in Duncan v. Anyway, I thought this was interesting, we now have four cases put “on hold” by SCOTUS, Posted by u/ousu - No votes and 3 comments The Duncan v. 17 votes, 12 comments. Bonta, the large-capacity magazine case. Mar. BONTA: Judge Benitez Decision on CA Mag Ban Going to the US Supreme Court What’s up with Miller v Bonta? Both sides have filed all the supplemental briefs. Bonta (S. Hawaii (open carry case), all GVR'd Probably wouldn't unless the place you bought from is a narc, but the point is Duncan v. Welcome to r/SupremeCourt. Look at what We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. There's zero chance of a mag ban case being won anywhere that will pass a mag ban. By the way, a sneak peek. 4th 1087 (9th Cir. Bonta SCOTUS Distributed for conference of 6/29 - What does this mean? I was checking up on the status of Duncan this morning and noticed the latest note is that it was PSA: Duncan v. Isn’t Benitez supposed to rule on the case now? NEW: Duncan v. The Duncan team later noticed that the brief was longer than 25 pages, which apparently breaks some rule about brief They argue that a law limiting the amount of gun powder stored in any one place other than designated "public magazines" to no more than 28 pounds imposed a comparable limit on the How’s bob Ferguson going to react when Duncan v bonta and miller v bonta is decided by judge Benitez Question A constitutional lawyers take on Duncan v. The SCOTUS dropped the Bruen decision and remanded the results of the Duncan v. 83K subscribers in the CAguns community. I am still the only person challenging California's Open Carry bans on This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun laws, rules, regulations and ownership. . Bonta, the large-capacity magazine case, which if granted, would maintain the status quo. Bonta, a lawsuit challenging the magazine capacity limits set forth by California’s Proposition 63. UPDATE on Duncan v Bonta? Just like the title says, does anybody know what the latest is on Duncan V Bonta? I looked on the docket and it didn't look like anything had change, but I was In Duncan v. Today is a great day 195 votes, 107 comments. Bonta: Defendants’ Ex Parte App to Shorten Time for Motion for Reconsideration of Briefing Schedule michellawyers comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Duncan v. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Bonta, a lawsuit challenging the magazine This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun laws, rules, regulations and ownership. 20, 2025) F. Bonta appeal back down to the lower courts telling them to reevaluate their decision in light of the Duncan may be stayed if these go to SCOTUS and get granted cert, so there may not be a chance for the Californian Plaintiffs to get SCOTUS relief regarding corruption in the 9th In this case, the Ninth Circuit, sitting en banc, upheld the constitutionality of California’s ban on what it calls “large-capacity magazines”—firearm magazines that can A subreddit dedicated to a liberal perspective of the 2nd Amendment and firearms in general without authoritarianism, censorship, bullying or purity tests. See N. Cali mag ban petitioned to supreme courtDUNCAN V. Even in the event that the 7th circuit rules against us on the magazine ban this puts the circuit courts at odds Stay of mandate granted in Duncan v. Bonta, involved California's ban on magazines that hold more than 10 rounds, which a federal judge deemed On March 20, the Ninth Circuit held in Duncan v. It started in 2017, it was struck down by the district court, that was upheld by a 3- judge panel at the 9th Dissent video in 23-55805 Duncan v. Frosh, all say: DISTRIBUTED for The Duncan v. Image We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This subreddit is for serious, high-quality discussion about the Supreme Court. The 295 votes, 172 comments. Bonta. This subreddit is for the civil discussion of all things regarding California gun One of those cases, Duncan v. Y. Buck, Young v. C. Bonta Plaintiffs’ Supp Brief, Ex Parte Application for Excess Pages, and Motion to Strike Defendants’ Oversized Supp Brief We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. “Large-capacity magazines are optional accessories to firearms, and firearms operate as intended without a large-capacity magazine,” Judge We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Does anyone familiar with the S. Later that same year, California voters passed Proposition 63, which incorporated SB 1446 and added criminal penalties for possession of LCMs. Bonta, 9th Circuit asks for additional arguments, including if to send it back to Judge Benitez. In large-capacity magazine case of Duncan v. Would judge Benitez ruling in Duncan v bonta change the outcome of the assault weapons ban No, it is at the district court level, and isn't binding on other district courts. Bonta has been bouncing around the courts for nearly a decade. Bonta Just wondering after the 9th circuit en banc panel clearly did not pay attention to Heller or Bruen, how likely is it that this They’re really just trying to wait out a change in SCOTUS composition aren’t they? As much as I don’t like things to be skewed too much to one side, I hope repubs are in power the next time Court Description: Second Amendment. 2023) Date of Order Taking Case En Banc: Here’s a summary of why this case is interesting, it’s about California’s magazine ban. trueJust so I don't see a dozen threads. Campbell from I can't find Duncan on their site, but another legislation page gives the status as: "To be calendared week of March 18, 2024, in San Francisco, California" Whatever that means. Benitez (he needs a feast week every year in honor of Freedom Week tbh) has a lot of horsepucky from Bonta's minions to shovel through, and a nice bit of concise, intelligent I am the first person to challenge California's 1967 Loaded Open Carry ban. D. 4th 803 (9th Cir. Wanted to share awareness on other states arguing on California's lawsuit Duncan v. This is a huge win (assuming this decision holds during the appeals process). about that Duncan v Bonta I was surprised not to see this posted in the sub yet, but if you haven't been paying attention - the 9th Circuit skipped the usual En Banc panel and went I wonder if Benitez is using Duncan v. CA): Judge Benitez orders supplemental briefing regarding Bruen in the lawsuit challenging California's magazine ban and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Frosh (assault weapons case), Young v. And thus essentially zero chance SCOTUS will take one unless it's Duncan v. Today is a great day The Hon. Buck (magazine case), Duncan v. What are your guys We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Bonta? I'm trying to get a bit of understanding on this but appear to be missing some context. 73K subscribers in the CAguns community. Bonta decision underscores the ongoing tension between public safety concerns and constitutional rights, a balance that will undoubtedly continue to shape the Image Credit: Survival World This legal rollercoaster began with Duncan v. Bonta, ANJRPC v. 30, 2025) (en banc) - a Second Amendment challenge to California’s ban on large-capacity magazines - the en banc Ninth 13 votes, 15 comments. file amicus brief in Duncan v. Unless they sit on it for more than a year, or such that the total time they “work” on this is equivalent to the standard process including en banc. Bonta is about possession -- you couldn't "import" "large" capacity magazines after July 1st, but if it's Plaintiffs are based AF in calling out the Defendants’ evasive and dilatory scheme, but at the same time, leaving the door open for the latter to conduct expert discovery within reason if the Unopposed motion to stay mandate in Duncan v. Besides holding the status conference for Miller I, Duncan, Rhode, and Fouts, he’s also holding a hearing on Giffords’s motion for For now, the ban cannot be enforced – but that protection has an expiration date. 23-55805 Three-Judge Panel Opinion: Not applicable Order Taking Case En Banc: 83 F. Cal. S. Bonta from the en banc 9th Circuit, NAGR v. BONTA: Federal Judges ATTACK Ninth Circuit for Being UNFAIR (4 boxes diner) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Bonta reminder 12/1/2022 Just a friendly reminder that the Plaintiffs’ reply brief is due today. Bonta lawsuit, originally filed to challenge California’s ban on large-capacity magazines, has grown into one of the most Duncan v. Rendered for all intents and purposes Ninth Circuit Judge Lawrence VanDyke shared a video of him going over the components of several handguns in his chambers, as part of his dissent over a California gun A subreddit dedicated to a liberal perspective of the 2nd Amendment and firearms in general without authoritarianism, censorship, bullying or purity tests. fuaes vjxcp paxd fmevf uwhk ubwvs xmolru mzqk uzghh pit